AI for CMOs

Should we put more marketing effort into retention or acquisition?

ShareLinkedIn

SimplSolutions editorial team · Pipeline & customers · 4 min read

Published · Updated

AI-assisted editorial guidance. Jordan is a fictional campaign character, not a verified human author. Worked examples are illustrative unless explicitly identified otherwise.

A retail manager and colleague reviewing a colorful store window display
Illustrative editorial image, not a customer result.

Find the constraint before choosing a budget split

Retention and acquisition solve different problems. A business with poor onboarding may lose the customers it just paid to acquire. A business with satisfied customers but too little qualified demand may need acquisition. The useful question is which specific intervention offers the best next improvement, not whether retention is always cheaper.

This guide helps a CMO compare a defined acquisition opportunity with a defined retention intervention. It does not prescribe a universal percentage or assume every customer can or should be retained.

Trace the customer journey with agreed definitions

Choose a cohort and follow it through first purchase, onboarding, use, repeat purchase or renewal where relevant. Define the denominator and time window at each stage. Comparing a new cohort with an older one before both have had the same opportunity to renew can be misleading.

Separate early failure to get started, dissatisfaction, changed needs, price objections and expected one-time use. Those causes call for different actions. A renewal email cannot fix a product that never delivered the promised value.

Check whether missing records or account structure distort the count. One parent company with several branches may appear as multiple customers in one report and a single account in another. Align the unit before calculating retention.

Compare actual interventions

OpportunityRequired evidenceCost to include
Improve onboardingWhere eligible customers get stuckContent, service effort and support
Clarify renewalDocumented confusion or missed processMessaging, operations and review
Win qualified new demandA defined audience and relevant offerMedia, creative, sales handling
Address unmet needsPermitted customer evidenceResearch and actual service changes

Do not compare an optimistic lifetime-value estimate for acquisition with a measured short-term cost for retention. Use compatible time horizons and explain what is estimated.

An illustrative decision

Suppose a cohort contains 100 new customers and 30 do not complete a required onboarding step. That tells you where to investigate, not that all 30 will become retained customers if you send another email.

Inspect why they stop. If the instructions are unclear, a better guide may help. If the service is unavailable at their location, marketing copy is not the remedy. Propose a bounded intervention and an observable result, such as completion of the correct step, before projecting revenue.

Compare the cost and expected uncertainty of that test with a specific acquisition campaign. There may be good reasons to fund both, but they should have separate owners and measures.

Jordan discussing local brand execution with operators

Illustrative editorial image, not a customer result.

Avoid retention messages that make the problem worse

Do not pressure customers to renew before resolving an outstanding service issue. Ensure the workflow can recognize appropriate exclusions using approved information and authorized access. A generic "we miss you" sequence can be poorly timed even when technically personalized.

Ask customer-facing staff for recurring questions and objections, using appropriately permitted evidence. AI can organize these questions, but simulated customers are not proof of what real customers need.

Measure the stage you actually changed

If the intervention fixes onboarding instructions, measure completion and support needs first. Later retention or revenue may depend on other events. Do not take credit for a downstream change without a credible comparison and an appropriate observation period.

Track who was eligible, who received the intervention and what changed. Note service changes, seasonality and promotions. If the definitions change, preserve the old and new rules so your trend is interpretable.

Prepare a portfolio of next decisions

For each opportunity, record the problem, eligible audience, proposed action, owner, total cost, evidence and downside. Rank based on your actual constraints and confidence, not a borrowed industry split. Include doing nothing when the problem is not yet understood.

Your immediate deliverable is one cohort map and two comparable test proposals. Use customer research responsibly to identify causes and the budget guide to compare commitments. Request a SimplSolutions demo if you need approved information connected to a reviewed customer workflow.

Jordan, your AI guide

Your role. Your questions.

Need CMO guidance?
Ask Jordan.

Talk through an idea, ask about the tools you already use, or find out what a first project could look like.

Jordan is a fictional campaign character and AI guide. Our team handles demo requests.