AI for CMOs

What should a CMO tell the board about AI progress?

ShareLinkedIn

SimplSolutions editorial team · Measurement · 4 min read

Published · Updated

AI-assisted editorial guidance. Jordan is a fictional campaign character, not a verified human author. Worked examples are illustrative unless explicitly identified otherwise.

Jordan walking with colleagues through a company workspace
Illustrative editorial image, not a customer result.

Report a decision, not a catalog of tools

A useful board update about marketing AI explains the business job, the evidence, total cost, remaining risk and the next requested commitment. Licenses purchased and assets generated show activity. They do not establish improved performance.

This guide provides a one-page structure that separates measured results from estimates and gives directors a decision they can evaluate. It does not require invented savings, a transformation narrative or a claim that every experiment succeeded.

Lead with the work and the reason it matters

Name a recurring problem such as incorrect local offers, excessive review effort or slow campaign preparation. Explain the consequence in plain language. Then state what was tested and what was deliberately excluded.

For example: "We tested preparing reviewed branch email drafts from approved offer facts. Live sending and budget changes were excluded." This gives the board a clear scope. "We deployed an intelligence layer" does not explain what changed for the business.

Put the evidence in a small table

FieldWhat to report
BaselineComparable accepted work before the test
ResultAccepted work and total effort during the test
QualityMaterial corrections, rejected output and exceptions
CostSetup, recurring tools and maintenance effort
LimitsSmall sample, missing baseline or changed conditions
Next decisionContinue, revise, expand or stop

Label every number measured, estimated or illustrative. If the baseline is recalled rather than recorded, say so. Do not present precision to two decimal places when the source is a rough staff estimate.

Explain cash and capacity separately

Suppose a pilot releases six staff-hours at an agreed $60 hourly rate. That is $360 of estimated capacity value before costs. It is not necessarily $360 less payroll. Name any actual expense reduced and where released capacity is being used.

If review effort increased, include it. If setup was expensive, distinguish the one-time investment from steady-state costs without hiding either. Show a downside scenario if workload or quality assumptions drive the proposed payback.

Use the ROI guide for the calculation. Avoid claims about increased sales unless you have evidence supporting that separate outcome.

Jordan discussing brand direction with portfolio-company leaders

Illustrative editorial image, not a customer result.

Describe risk as a specific operating gap

Replace "AI has risks" with the observed issue and control. For example: "Two test drafts used an expired offer. The source owner corrected the authority rule; those cases will be retested before any live workflow is considered."

Do not claim a control is effective merely because it exists in a document. Report which exceptions were actually tested and which remain untested. Appropriate security, privacy and commercial owners still need to approve their own areas.

Mention the person accountable for maintenance and source changes. A pilot with no operating owner is not ready to become a permanent service, even if the first results look encouraging.

Ask for the next bounded commitment

State the resources, decision owner, evaluation period and evidence required. An expansion request might fund testing additional campaign types under the same acceptance rules. It should not silently add live publishing or broader data access.

Include the alternative use of the resources. If source cleanup could solve the problem more cheaply, the board should see that option. A credible proposal includes the possibility of stopping.

Handle an inconclusive pilot honestly

If the evidence is too weak, say what is missing and what it would cost to resolve. An inconclusive test can still reveal a source defect or an unsuitable job. Do not turn that discovery into a claimed productivity win.

Avoid a long list of lessons without a decision. Recommend a narrower retest, a process correction or no further spending, and explain why. Directors should not have to infer the requested action from the final slide.

Use this final paragraph structure

"We tested [job] using [approved inputs]. Compared with [baseline], accepted completion changed by [measured result] at [quality standard]. Total cost was [basis]. The remaining uncertainty is [gap]. We request [next commitment] to resolve [decision]. We will stop or revise if [condition]."

Attach the underlying evidence, not every generated draft. Compare budget alternatives before making the request. For a demonstration centered on one accountable workflow, talk to SimplSolutions.

Jordan, your AI guide

Your role. Your questions.

Need CMO guidance?
Ask Jordan.

Talk through an idea, ask about the tools you already use, or find out what a first project could look like.

Jordan is a fictional campaign character and AI guide. Our team handles demo requests.